117 Comments
User's avatar
Linda Neary's avatar

We must oppose terrorism, starvation, genocide, oppression, annihilation wherever it may be. We must say never again. Not on our watch. For all of humanity.

Jeff Houlahan's avatar

Mark J Carney – Shameful PM of the Day. Imagine this – here’s what Carney wrote about Trump’s plan for Gaza.

Canada welcomes President Trump's historic new Middle East peace plan, and we urge all parties to help it realise its full potential.

As the critical next step, Hamas must immediately release all hostages.

Mark’s willingness to lick Trump’s boots has never been more transparently obvious.

So, what is Mark Carney’s record on Gaza?

No arms embargo.

No economic sanctions.

No adherence or support for international law.

Allowing Israel to hold all Palestinians in Gaza hostage in exchange for ‘recognition’ of Palestine.

Support for the ‘Trump’ plan for Gaza. A plan developed by Netanyahu and Trump, to be led by Tony Blair and Donald Trump and designed to enrich Trump and cronies. A plan the UN Special Rapporteur for Palestine has characterized as ‘The Trap of the Century’

A call for the 20 Israeli hostages to be released immediately with no mention of the thousands of Palestinian hostages – men, women and children. That’s right. Children. - held in Israeli prisons without charges or due process.

Rightful condemnation of the attack on the Manchester synagogue, but no mention of the sniper attack on Marwan Abdeen, a nurse at the Yassar Medical Complex in Gaza.

Are we surprised that Mark wasn’t able to take a few minutes and a few steps from his office to join people from across Canada to honour and remember some of the children murdered in Gaza by saying their names aloud? The degree to which Carney takes immoral and unprincipled positions on Palestine shocks and shames me more than it surprises me. So, refusing to Say Their Names doesn’t even make the long list of Carney’s shameful acts.

Jennifer Dales's avatar

You mention that Canada has banned Kneecap. So far, all I can find on the matter is that an MP made a video of himself where he speaks "on behalf of the Government of Canada" and states that Canada has banned them. The band itself has not been notified of any ban. Yet the media keeps repeating this statement as a fact. The IRCC won't say anything for privacy reasons. I wonder if we will ever know if that group has actually been banned...

Ed Buckner's avatar

With respect, your answer omits a huge, overwhelmingly large factor: Hamas. And Hamas's willingness to sacrifice the people of Gaza for their fucked up religious beliefs matters.

Rod Hill's avatar

It is sad that David Lametti has chosen to say things like this that he surely does not believe, in exchange for getting this appointment as Ambassador to the UN. He should be criticized for that while clearly identifying the source of this lie: Mark Carney, on whose desk the buck stops. Remember that a few months ago the PM was asked a question at a public event that use the word "genocide". When he was criticized afterwards for answering the question as if he had accepted that genocide was taking place, he pretended that he had not heard that word so that he could avoid addressing the issue.

Christine Burkart's avatar

UBC and Goole define an ambassador's duties quite clearly, and our U.S. Ambassador only excels at representing his government, and there is no way we can bend to a fascist regime. He might protect his own personal staff, however that doesn't help Canada, at least I can't see a benefit to us.

He is not protecting Canadian citizens, as he just repeats what his boss says. Trade, negotiations and sharing values is a moot subject with us. He is occupying the embassy, it seems, to further antagonize us with adjectives used by Grade One children…'mean' and 'nasty'. Is it possible to ask our dear friends in the Netherlands how they ousted him…maybe we can too. It's childish enough to listen to that rhetoric from afar, let alone on our home ground.

Deb's avatar

In my opinion that is a disgraceful statement for the Ambassador for Canada to make. Anyone with eyes to see can see by videos & ears to hear on the news that Israel is withholding food & forced starvation by withholding aid to the Palestinians is a form of cruel, slow agonizing genocide. No one needs to “wait for all the evidence “ . If you have a conscience & any kind of humanity left in your heart, those starving Palestinians can’t wait for some one to make a deidiom on whether they have determined what is going on is genocide of the Palestinians.

Klaus Offermann's avatar

My brain freezes and struggles for words when I try to process the malevolent scale of the unspeakable horrors visited upon Palestinians by Israel and America. My soul bleeds sorrow and at times I am full of rage against the leaders of the nations of the world. I can not find language adequate to express the condemnation they deserve for their cowardice. To my grave I will not forgive their inaction.

Leaders like Lametti who hide behind diplomatic & bureaucratic methods of control and language designed to water down the public narrative and to avoid facing up to the obvious:

• More than sixty-four thousand are dead, crushed and obliterated – mostly children, women and babies in wombs. Murdered as far as I am concerned.

• A long overdue need for comprehensive, worldwide sanctions, boycotts and as you say “steps to stop the deliberate starvation of children.”

• The urgent need for leaders of the nations of the world, to vigorously and honestly confront the brutal Bibi/Trump genocidal death machine.

Every body knows it is genocide.

Everybody knows that waiting for a legal determination of genocide from Lametti’s “international body of authority that rules in that manner” will be too late and will likely facilitate a complete genocide in Gaza. I can’t go on.. my brain is freezing up again.. Thank you Charlie for articulating the cruel truth.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XiSWSFcEXfw

..“Tell the universe where you've been

With your bloodstained shoes and your dunce's grin”..

“Tell the universe what you took

While the heavens trembled and the mountains shook

All those lives not worth a second look

Tell the universe what you took”

Susan Clement-Faught's avatar

On Monday Carney said at the UN in NY...It’s necessary in our judgment… The possibility, in absolute violation of the UN Charter and in absolute violation of international law, of self‑determination for the Palestinian peoples is being erased.” I mean isn't he in a sense acknowledging the genocide in Gaza by Netanyahu.

Sharon Siba's avatar

I fully believe Netanyahu and his cronies who get themselves elected in a dictator-like election want a genocide of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip. It's certain Netanyahu will never recognize a Palestinian State. He's been tried and found guilty of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Lametti was wrong in saying what he said.

That being said, it seems unfair to blame only Israelis for attempting a genocide. Doesn't anyone remember when extremist Muslims in some Middle Eastern countries took over? I certainly do! Those leaders declared a genocide of Jews. They still do. The leaders of those same Middle Eastern countries man and fund Hamas, Hezbollah and Houthis groups in Palestine.

Don't try to tell me Hamas, Hezbollah and Houthis have behaved any better than Netanyahu and the IDU? They have not. The only reason they haven't killed as many innocent Jews is that their weapons haven't been as powerful as yet. But they will never allow an Israeli State any more than Netanyahu will allow a Palestinian State.

Susan T's avatar

The declaration that Palestine is a state is meaningless as long as we support the State of Israel and worse, send arms and ammunition so that they can continue their genocide. Our government has been lying to us about sending arms to Israel. When they aren't sending them directly, they send them to the US who then sends them to Israel read the report at this site: armsembargonow.ca then click on "read the report"

IM Citizen's avatar

And then there's this. We care. We love. We cuddle. We Canadian! We'll be like the baby beaver and thrive...

https://youtu.be/qVyws4MFHhA?si=5BA4IZ9zs9XHZTLc

Ron's avatar

Everyone except the U.S., Great Britain, Canada, Argentina and Israel. It's obvious that what Israel is doing is ethnic cleansing. they're trying to eliminate the Palestinian people under the guise of protecting their country from a handful of Hamas fighters. All they have to do is agree to stop the massacre permanently, and I'm sure Hamas would willingly hand over any hostages remaining.

Bill's avatar

UN Ambassador Bob Rae didn't hesitate to use the word genocide (when it came to Russia):

"It never ceases to amaze me that we are allowing genocidal maniacs to set the terms of engagement. The world should not be powerless to stop a genocide we can see happen with our own eyes in real time."

https://x.com/BobRae48/status/1610433429983854593

"Well, a murderous campaign to kill thousands and destroy schools, hospitals, blow up chemical plants and launch a genocide doesn’t come to mind as a response."

https://x.com/BobRae48/status/1532043716164296704

"This is what justifies the genocide. Denying a people exist makes killing them a non-event. There is a deep sickness in Russia that cannot be denied. The demons have been unleashed, and depravity is the consequence."

https://x.com/BobRae48/status/1517835810871066624

"The Russians don’t care about the Geneva Conventions, the Hague Conventions, the Nuremberg Protocols, the Genocide Convention, the Torture Convention, the Rome Statute, war crimes or crimes against humanity. They believe in one thing, brute force. This is who we are dealing with"

https://x.com/BobRae48/status/1535628391063371782

Elizabeth Oliver-Malone's avatar

of course the Idf and netanyahu government are doing genocide --self styled-the eternal victims --as we ask "How many eyes for an eye--" (Leviticus) and the answer is all -as they see themselves as eternal victims fighting for all of the area----I agree with Michael Jones--and we don't want to trade with them . Next are the Christians who are only tolerated to bring in Tourists--the tourist trade is down a lot

Michael Jones's avatar

While I'm very pleased that Canada has recognized the State of Palestine, much more is needed, and at light speed. Immediately recall our Ambassador from Israel, immediately cease ALL trade (particularly military exchanges of any sort), and impose the same sanctions on Israel that we imposed on South Africa before it's transformation.

Sandy Bauer's avatar

I understand your positive reaction to Canada's recognition of the state of Palestine, but I can't help but note that it's meaningless. It accomplishes nothing for the people of Palestine. Alto the other actions you suggest (although probably too late) would restore my pride at being a Canadian