67 Comments

Many thanks for stepping up with this initiative! No backing down from bullies! A quibble though: I get directed to Facebook when I try to share the petition. I can probably figure out a workaround but do you want Facebook to be a part of this? Your call…just putting it out there….

Expand full comment

Why Trump changed the borders on the “Gulf of Mexico” He's checking the “Outrage Barometer” to see whether he can get away with! 🤔 Next is Canada's 🇨🇦 Borders 😡

Expand full comment

It's not meant seriously..... But sometimes it's interesting to change your perspective.

Isn't it usually the case that the bigger one takes over the smaller one? So the question would not be whether Canada should become the 51st state of the USA, but whether the USA should be allowed to become a province of Canada! (Even if nobody wants that) :-)

But seriously: As a German, I got to know a great country with lovely people during a vacation in Canada. It is not without reason that Canada enjoys a high reputation and a lot of sympathy in Europe. The same applies in South America. The USA has a bad reputation there.

The EU has concluded a free trade agreement with Mercosur, the common market in South America. This opens up many opportunities. Canada, the EU, the UK and South America form a market with many natural resources, a lot of know-how and over a billion people - more than three times as many as in the USA. In addition, Greenland, which is currently in the headlines, lies on the axis between Canada and Europe. I think that the Greenlanders would rather be an equal partner between peace-loving neighbors than a territory occupied by US troops.

The countries I mentioned have another thing in common: they try to avoid military conflicts as much as possible.

Perhaps we should see this weirdo in the Oval Office as an opportunity to reshuffle the cards.....

Expand full comment

I would like to know where JD Vance’s best friend from Yale, MP Jivani is. He went to the inauguration to “support VP Vance and restore US/Canadian relationship”. Haven’t heard anything since. Is he standing up for Canada? I realize Vance has very little clout in the administration (Trump wouldn’t say he would be his successor) but it would be nice to know Jivani is trying to bring some wisdom and clarity here!

Expand full comment

U.S. citizen here…We are no longer using Amazon…deleting those from fb who I know to be Trumpers. We have been buying Canadian for a few years…TruEarth and Open Farm. Will be traveling to Canada as soon as passports and visas are in place. Please find the video of Musk, his son and Trump in the Oval Office during the press conference last week…it had me roflmao!

Expand full comment

As a convicted felon, the man in the White House should be denied entry into Canada for the G7 summit. We REALLY don't want him soiling our beautiful country. Can he be kept out?

Expand full comment

A secured Relationship with America? There is no such thing as Secure Relationship. America is a FOREIGN FASCIST COUNTRY THAT BELIEVES IN DOMINATING THE WORLD. No matter the cost. Allies or Adversaries all are ENEMIES TO THE USA. Sanctions,Tariffs,MILITARY INTERVENTIONS,PROXY WARS, COUPS is what AMERICAN FASCISTS THRIVE ON, even at the SUFFERING OF THEIR OWN CITIZENS. International Law,World Rule Based Order,HUMAN RIGHTS , SOVEREIGNTY OF OTHER COUNTRIES ( Canadian Values) are not visible or followed by Fascist America . Unless those values are construed for their FASCIST NEEDS AND DOMINANCE OVER ADVERSARIES OR ALLIES . BRICS IS THE PATHWAY TO CANADIAN SOVEREIGNTY

Expand full comment

The Pledge for Canada is a rallying cry for resistance, but resistance alone isn’t enough. What we need now is a framework for transformation—a new approach that directly addresses the collapsed paradigms and untenable status quo that brought us to this point. The Perfect Political Platform offers exactly that: a one-term roadmap to restructure the systems that have failed us, create space for bold ideas, and elevate solutions that serve Canadians first.

https://sonderuncertainly.substack.com/p/the-perfect-political-platform

It’s not about perpetuating the same divisive, patchwork governance—it’s about bringing people together to envision how we navigate this moment of global instability, technological disruption, and systemic collapse. From electoral reform to transparent accountability mechanisms to leveraging technology for collective empowerment, the PPP is the kind of forward-thinking, multidisciplinary framework that recognizes both the scale of the challenges and the opportunities for real change.

Canada can’t afford to simply defend what we have. We must also reimagine and rebuild for a future that prioritizes the well-being of every Canadian and protects us from being subsumed by external pressures. This is the way forward.

Expand full comment

Well said Charlie:

"We cannot turn away from our historic role of being a humanitarian friend to deal with the suffering in the world...."

Canada has an urgent role to play mitigating some of the harm from USAID's apparent closure & disturbing developments at the Pentagon:

https://open.substack.com/pub/greghansen/p/as-us-actions-imperil-the-lives-of?r=38ktr&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Expand full comment

JUST signed up for Substack because of you… I was on YouTube and saw how you spoke and the passion in your words. I couldn’t have been prouder to be a Canadian at that moment, THANK YOU!!!

I’m joining the pledge and will do my part to show the world how strong and united we are as a nation!!!

Wish you were in Winnipeg, I’d love to shake your hand and personally thank you for standing up for OUR Country!!!❤️

Expand full comment

Canada will hold the line!

Expand full comment

Done, could you please run for Prime Minister? 🙏

Expand full comment

Why not have a pledge for American friends of Canada?

Expand full comment

Charlie and Group, thank you for initiating this opportunity to allow we citizens to publicly demonstrate Canadian solidarity. Your thoughtful, well articulated pledge is appreciated.

Expand full comment

Signed it a couple of days ago and posted on Bluesky to encourage others as well. Thanks for standing up for Canada and all Canadians.

Expand full comment

For an excellent insight into the best verbal playbook

check out BBC with mark carney titled:

YOU TUBE "We're going to stand up to a bully" | Mark Carney on President Trump’s Canada trade tariffs

Expand full comment